Which wipers are better – framed or frameless: nuances of choice

Issues discussed in the material:

• What are the advantages and disadvantages of frame and frameless wipers
• Which wipers should you prefer?
• Is there an alternative to frame and frameless wipers?

Sooner or later there comes a time when the windshield wiper blades stop functioning normally. Then the car owner must find suitable wipers. The problem is that stores offer a huge number of different types of brushes. Therefore, it is difficult for the driver to make a choice among the many brands and design options. It is important to choose brushes that clean the glass well, are inexpensive and look good. In today’s article, we’ll figure out which wipers are better: framed or frameless.

Advantages and disadvantages of frame and frameless wipers

1. Frame wipers.

In frame wipers, the rubber strip that cleans the glass is attached to a metal frame. It consists of several levers that are connected to each other using hinges. These arms are commonly called "rocker arms".

The attachment point for the leash is located on the very top lever. The frame is necessary so that the distribution of the pressing force from the leash is uniform. It also gives the brush sufficient lateral rigidity. To make the rubber band more rigid, two strips of steel are placed in its grooves.

What are the advantages of frame wipers:

• low cost when compared with similar brushes of another type;
• thanks to the rocker arms, frame brushes are used on glass with different curvatures;
• you can install a new rubber band;
• Budget-friendly, you can purchase such brushes at any auto store.

Minuses:

• in the cold season, the frame may freeze and become immobile;
• increased windage, so frame brushes do not effectively clean the glass if the car is moving at high speed;
• look unaesthetic.

2. Frameless wipers.

Despite the name, frameless brushes still have a frame. However, it is made in the form of a curved spring plate made of steel, which is located inside the cleaning tape.

It is due to the plate that the brush is obtained with a specific profile and is suitable for the glass of a particular car. There are also universal products.

The calculated working curvature of the brush does not change during operation, no matter how fast the car goes or how low the ambient temperature drops.

We recommend

“How to change wipers on a car: we understand the design and manufacturers” Read more
Frameless wipers have the following feature: when the blade profile is suitable for the windshield of your car, it will clean it perfectly, and the pressure along the entire length of the wiper will be uniform. Otherwise, there will be uncleaned areas on the glass, even though the brush is brand new.

What are the advantages of frameless wipers:

• the entire surface of the brush is evenly pressed against the glass, provided that the profile of the product is suitable;
• excellent aerodynamic qualities: due to the low profile, the brush cleans the glass, even if the car is moving at high speed;
• In winter, frameless wipers practically do not freeze.

Minuses:

• the high cost of frameless brushes compared to frame ones;
• The brushes are not universal; there is a risk that they will not be suitable for your car.

When do brushes need to be replaced?

The answer is more than obvious: when the car owner sees that the brushes have become unusable, do not remove water or dirt, and leave streaks, it’s time to throw them away. Wipers are a consumable item and should be replaced after several seasons. Another “bell” that reminds you to replace the brushes can be a situation where, due to a worn brush, a water film remains on the glass. It impairs visibility at night and increases the brightness of headlights from an oncoming car. Such situations require immediate replacement of old wipers with new ones.

Which wiper blades are better: framed or frameless?

To answer the question of which wipers are better, framed or frameless, specifically for your car, you need to find out what the car manufacturer recommends.

Before purchasing a part, please consider:

• Dimensions of frame or frameless brushes
  . The length should be as recommended by the car manufacturer. If the brush is too long, the pressing force will be small. Short blades will not clean the windshield completely.
• Features of fastening
  - it is best if it is a universal and durable hook.
• Part integrity
  . Before you buy brushes, look to see if they have any cracks, chips, etc.
• The rubber band must be of high quality
  , not afraid of low temperatures, exposure to ultraviolet radiation, rain, and the like.
• Resistance to icing
  . Which wipers are better - framed or frameless if you live in regions with cold winters? In this case, preference should be given to the second option. The efficiency of frame wipers will be much lower.
• Working at speed
  . Frame wipers will not clean the windshield well. But frameless ones do not lose their qualities with increasing speed.
• Windshield bend
  . A universal option is frame wipers that are suitable for any car.
• Price
  . Frameless wipers will have to be changed frequently, and their cost is higher than that of frame ones. If you want to save money, it is better to purchase frame brushes and simply replace the rubber band with them.

Even if you buy the best windshield wipers, it doesn’t matter whether they are framed or frameless, if the windshield is scratched, the view will still be poor. Therefore, first of all, it is recommended to install new glass or polish the old one.

Choosing new windshield wipers

When choosing new wipers, you should first of all follow the recommendations from the vehicle manufacturer!

When purchasing, you must rely on:

1. blade length - always stick to the recommended size, long wipers will have less pressing force, and shorter ones will not provide the necessary visibility.
2. universal fastening - the most common and reliable option is a hook.
3. appearance - when purchasing, be sure to inspect new wipers for cracks, chips and other damage.
4. quality of rubber - the material must be frost-resistant and resistant to aggressive environmental influences.
5. cost - remember - a high-quality model cannot be very cheap!

If your car's windshield is very old and has multiple scratches, it will need to be replaced or sanded before installing new wipers because... No brushes will create excellent visibility with old glass.

Top 12 best frame and frameless wipers

Which wipers to buy: frame or frameless, determine based on the characteristics of the car and your driving style, as well as the climate in which you live. We have compiled a rating of the top wipers of 2018-2019. To make it more convenient, the list is divided into the best framed and frameless models.

The best frame models of wipers:

1. Bosch Twin are among the top best frame brushes from this German manufacturer. High-quality windshield wipers perfectly remove dirt from the windshield. The main advantage is two-component rubber. Its base is thin and soft, while the working surface is harder, due to this the brushes perfectly clean the surface. The hook with which the brushes are attached makes installation and dismantling quick and easy. The noise of the brushes is reduced, their movement is soft and smooth. The high-quality closed frame is made of metal and is not afraid of corrosion. There are no disadvantages to these frame wipers. Experts advise using them in the winter season, as well as when the glass is heavily soiled. The cost of products starts from 850 rubles.
2. Valeo Silencio Performance . The main feature of these frame brushes is their smooth and silent operation. The degree of surface cleansing is maximum. The blades have six attachment points, as well as a color indicator that shows when the wipers are worn out and it's time to replace them. The fastening is a hook, and these wipers also do not have additional adapters, so this model is not universal. The price starts from 800 rubles.
3. Heyner exclusive . The wipers are suitable for any windshield, since suitable adapters can be purchased in the kit. Advantages - the rubber band is replaceable, you can install a new one as soon as the old one wears out. The downside is that the brushes do not clean the surface perfectly. You can purchase these frame wipers for a price starting from 450 rubles.
4. Champion Aerovantage . They are available in different lengths and with different fastenings, so this model is considered the most universal. The main advantage is that the brushes clean the surface perfectly. However, many car owners note that the hinges quickly become unusable due to the heavy weight of the structure. The cost is on average 700 rubles.
5. Bosch Eco . If your budget is limited, then the best frame brushes for you are Bosh Eco, their price is 250–300 rubles. Their rubber is made from natural rubber, which means that the brushes will perfectly clean the windshield. The metal frame is powder-coated, so it is not afraid of corrosion. To make the sliding of the frame brushes smooth and silent, the brush blade is coated with graphite.
6. Champion X51e - wipers made in Italy with increased reliability. Due to the tight fit of the brushes, they perfectly clean the surface. Snow will not stick to these wipers. The only drawback is that the brushes can creak during operation. These products cannot be called budget, because their price starts from 520 rubles.

We recommend

“How to change frameless wipers: complete instructions” Read more
The best frameless wipers:

1. Denso WB-Flat Blade . If you are looking for the best frameless brushes, then pay attention to this model with high clamping force. Their special shape allows for high aerodynamic performance. Low degree of icing at sub-zero temperatures. The brushes perfectly clean even dry dirt from the surface. You can purchase adapters in the kit, so you can install the product on any car. Suitable for use at any time of the year. The only negative is the short service life. Price 500-700 rubles.
2. Valeo Silencio X-TRM . If you are looking for the best frameless wipers that will last a long time, then pay attention to this model. The brushes are made of durable material, resistant to sudden temperature changes, and effectively clean glass even in severe frost. Due to the specific shape of the blade - the working edge is at the top - wipers are able to make the windshield clean quickly, even if you are driving at high speed. The brushes move smoothly and silently. Thanks to the convenient Multiclip mount, you can quickly and easily mount the brushes. The only negative is that there are no adapters on sale, and the price of these frameless wipers reaches 900–1,000 rubles.
3. Bosch Aerotwin - brushes that are created using the latest developments. Even without adapters, they can be installed on almost all machines. They perfectly clean the surface due to the high degree of pressure, as well as special rubber, which contains silicone. Eliminates any contamination and is not afraid of low sub-zero temperatures. The ride is smooth and silent. The main disadvantage is the short period of use. After 6 months you will have to install new brushes. The price is small - only 500–600 rubles.
4. Heyner All Seasons - are not afraid of corrosion, the brushes have a graphite coating, the sliding is almost silent, the brushes are in close contact with the surface. The rubber band can be changed as it wears out. The price of the model is 500 rubles.
5. Alca Super Flat is the best frameless wipers for winter, made in Germany. Made from a material with increased strength that is not afraid of low temperatures. These flat brushes have an attractive appearance. They do not “strip”; they remove snow and ice from the surface of the glass. The only drawback is that they lose their quality when exposed to ultraviolet radiation. Cost - 450 rubles.
6. Goodyear FRAMELESS - brushes have increased reliability and are not afraid of low temperatures. Special guides are made of stainless steel. Due to graphite coating, the brushes operate silently and smoothly. High degree of cleaning, wipers do not “strip”. A universal model, its installation is easy and quick, no adapters are required, because the Multiclip fastening system is used. Cost 450–500 rubles.

An alternative to frame and frameless wipers - hybrid

If you don’t know which wipers are better – framed or frameless, pay attention to the most efficient hybrid models. They are small in size, the frame is located under the casing.

They combine all the advantages of frame and frameless brushes. Made from high density rubber.

Universal hybrid brushes can be mounted on any glass. What are the advantages of such models:

• increased clamping capacity;
• perfectly cleanses any dirt;
• high aerodynamic characteristics;
• low height of products;
• long service life.

Despite the advantages, hybrid brushes have their disadvantages:

• price;
• Snow sticks to them during snowfall.

We recommend

“The wipers do not work: the cause of the malfunction and their elimination” Read more
Top hybrid models:

1. Denso Hybrid Wiper Blade - copes well with any type of contamination due to a tape with increased elasticity, as well as a metal frame. Suitable for winter use, these high quality products can be purchased at an affordable price. Installation is easy and quick. You can also purchase adapters, so the brushes are suitable for any car. This model has no significant disadvantages. That is why they open the top of the best hybrid brushes. The price starts from 600 rubles.
2. Valeo First Covertech - due to the elastic but durable edge of the brushes, they remove any dirt. Plastic casing with an aerodynamic shape. Thanks to the universal fastening, you can handle the installation of brushes without any problems. The movement is smooth, despite their efficient operation, the wipers will last a long time. The only drawback is the price, which starts from 1,000 rubles.
3. Heyner hybrid - if you need inexpensive hybrid brushes, then pay attention to this model. They do not clean dirt well, especially around the edges, which is explained by the low price of the products. The price is 350–400 rubles, the same as for frame brushes.
4. Trico neoform - made in Mexico, they are distinguished by uniform surface cleaning. However, they may leave streaks. Made from natural rubber, the edges are coated with graphite, making the brushes move smoothly and silently. The price of the products is too high - 1,000 rubles.
5. Sparco SPC are brushes that can be used both in winter and summer. They operate silently and clean dirt well. Universal mount. There is one drawback - the cost starts from 1,000 rubles.
6. Goodyear HYBRID - made of high-strength, wear-resistant materials. This is why these hybrid brushes will last a long time. Suitable for use in any season, not afraid of icing. Due to the aerodynamic shape, they clean effectively, do not “streak”, and do not leave streaks. The cost starts from 600 rubles.

conclusions

It is important to understand that the advantages and disadvantages of frame and frameless wipers presented in the article, as well as advice on which brushes are better in a particular situation, are based only on the design features of the wiper. However, the store will offer you specific models from a variety of manufacturers. Everyone has good and unsuccessful models, there are defects or fakes, it may turn out that a high-quality frame brush will cope with cleaning glass better than a more expensive, but low-quality frameless one.

Therefore, we recommend that before making the final choice, look at tests of windshield wiper blades and read reviews of specific wiper models.

And one more interesting point. On our website we organized a survey among readers “What type of windshield wipers do you use?” and here are the results

Maybe the opinion of our readers will help you decide on the type of wipers.